17 Nov 2026

The Railways Bill - which aims to define how Great British Railways will operate - moves to the Report Stage in the House of Lords tomorrow (18th November). However, we contest that the Bill is full of loopholes for privatisation, with serious failures in parliamentary scrutiny. We Own It, The Association of British Commuters and Bring Back British Rail have jointly written to Heidi Alexander (Secretary of State for Transport) and Lord Hendy (Minister of State for Rail) urging for greater transparency about the bill and asking for an urgent response to our concerns.

The letter

Dear Secretary of State and Lord Hendy,

We write to object to the serious threats to public ownership in the Railways Bill and failures in Parliament’s scrutiny of the legislation.

The Railways Bill will effectively repeal the Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Act 2024 in its entirety, overturning its central principle that train operators must be wholly publicly owned.

In its current form, the Bill would mean that:

Furthermore, a new government amendment tabled for the Lords Report Stage suggests that core railway functions could be performed by private sector companies, acting as agents for GBR.

These features of the Bill would leave infrastructure management, railway passenger services, ticket retail, cross network facilities, research and development and other core functions vulnerable to partial privatisation. They would overturn the public-ownership protections established by the 2024 Act and the Government’s manifesto commitment to bring passenger rail services into public ownership.

Parliament must be fully informed

We believe that the government has failed to properly explain these matters. Recent Lords Committee debates suggest a widespread belief that the 2024 Act remains in place, while ministers have failed to explain the position and even contributed to the misunderstanding. Additionally, misleading comments made by the rail minister in regard to the part-privatisation of GBR subsidiaries have not been corrected and remain on the Parliamentary record.

A further cause of these misunderstandings was a government amendment made at the Commons Report Stage of the Bill that Great British Railways’ parent company would be ‘wholly’ publicly owned. Because the organisational structure of GBR has not been disclosed, this gave the impression that the entire railway benefited from this protection. In fact, GBR will comprise multiple legal entities, and in fact only the central functions of strategy, timetabling and access decisions are certain to be protected. This leaves any other GBR function under clause 3(1) eligible for part-privatisation or outsourcing to a private company.

Partial private ownership of GBR companies

At the Commons report stage of the Bill, the Government quietly made amendments to define Great British Railways (GBR) companies as ‘subsidiaries’ under the meaning of section 1159 of the Companies Act 2006. This means that almost any railway function could end up part-owned by the private sector, through a range of private shareholding arrangements, including private investors owning just under 50% of a company - provided that GBR retains a controlling stake.

This definition was chosen instead of ‘wholly-owned subsidiaries’, also available under section 1159 of the Companies Act 2006. This much more obvious choice would have aligned with the 2024 Act, which required that public sector companies always be ‘wholly owned’ by the public. This definition would still allow a broad range of partnerships with the private sector as can be seen in the example of Platform4, a wholly owned subsidiary of Network Rail. Platform4 has a variety of joint ventures in property development, even as a minority partner, and there is no need for a ‘subsidiary’ status to enable this.

Private companies could exercise GBR’s statutory functions

A new government amendment would allow ‘any other person’, including a private company, to carry out GBR’s ‘statutory or other functions’ on its behalf. This leaves the door open to private companies taking on core parts of running the railway. The tabled amendment to clause 3 seems to apply to all the functions listed in clause 3(1), containing no protection to keep vital functions, such as infrastructure management, in public hands.

Inadequate safeguards for passenger services

The Bill lacks safeguards to ensure that mainline passenger services are secured only from public sector companies, overturning one of the main achievements of the 2024 Act. The provisions of Chapter 1 of Part 2 are extremely vague and problematic, containing loopholes that could allow a return to commissioning services from private companies. Firstly, while the Secretary of State ‘may’ secure services through a direct award to a public sector company, there is no provision for those services she does not personally secure and no explanation of who else can award these contracts and on what basis. Secondly, provisions for the exemption of services from GBR are excessively broad and could enable a wide range of private contracting arrangements.

Weakening the Public Sector Equality Duty

A further issue created by the repeal of the 2024 Act is that train operators will no longer be fully subject to the Public Sector Equality Duty (PSED). The Bill adds only GBR’s parent company to the PSED Schedule, and the Government has opposed amendments that attempted to add ‘GBR companies’ to this listing. An additional weakening of PSED is set to occur in relation to the Equality Act 2010 (Specific Duties and Public Authorities) Regulations 2017, which requires public authorities to publish equality objectives and information. Schedule 2 to these regulations currently lists Network Rail Ltd, but there is no provision in the Bill to replace this with GBR.

Urgent priorities for the Railways Bill

These are not minor drafting issues or organisational details. This Bill will shape the railway for decades to come and yet the door is being left open for privatisation across the entire railway - an exceptionally dangerous power to leave in the hands of a future government.

The lack of transparency surrounding such fundamental issues has been unacceptable and wasted crucial parliamentary opportunities to find compromises. Many other approaches are available, but it has been impossible to propose these because the government has not made clear its real objectives.

We therefore ask the Ministers to fully address these matters on the floor of both Houses before any further votes on the Bill, and bring forward amendments to:

  1. Define GBR companies as ‘wholly-owned subsidiaries’ under section 1159 of the Companies Act 2006.
  2. Ensure all GBR statutory functions stay in the public sector, including clear protections for train operators and infrastructure managers.
  3. Include safeguards ensuring contracts for mainline passenger services can only be awarded to public sector companies.
  4. Make GBR companies fully subject to the Public Sector Equality Duty.

These protections are necessary to uphold the principles agreed by Parliament in the 2024 Act and prevent their erosion by this or a future government.

We look forward to your urgent response.

Yours sincerely,

Emily Sullivan, Association of British Commuters

Cat Hobbs, We Own It

Ellie Harrison, Bring Back British Rail


REFERENCES

1 The Railways Bill, Schedule 4, para 11 repeals sections 23 to 31 and 83(1) of the Railways Act 1993, representing most of the sections inserted by the Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Act 2024. It also renders the Public Sector Equality Duty ineffective, since this refers to train operating contracts awarded under section 30, which is repealed; as well as minor amendments to section 73, since these refer to section 24, which is repealed. Taken together, these changes replace the 2024 Act in its entirety.

2 The Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Act 2024, section 2(3) inserted section 30C into the Railways Act 1993, which defined a ‘public sector company’ as a company wholly owned by the Secretary of State, the Welsh Ministers or the Scottish Ministers. However, the Bill defines GBR companies as ‘subsidiaries’ under section 1159 of the Companies Act 2006 (Schedule 4, paras 73(3), 80, 90(3)).

3 The Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Act 2024, section 2(2) inserted section 30(1A) into the Railways Act 1993, requiring that passenger services could only be secured by making a direct award of a public sector contract to a public sector company – a provision that captured any ‘relevant franchising authority.’ This certainty is lost under clauses 25(1) and 31(1) of the Railways Bill, which require that the Secretary of State ‘must designate railway passenger services, or a description of railway passenger services’ but only ‘may’ secure the provision of those services through direct award to a public sector company.

4 The Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Act 2024, section 3, added train operating companies to Part 1 of Schedule 19 of the Equality Act 2010, making them fully subject to the Public Sector Equality Duty (PSED). However, the entry refers to companies operating under ‘a public service contract awarded under section 30 of the Railways Act 1993’, a provision that will no longer exist, thus effectively removing train operators from the Schedule.

5 Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill’s amendment, Clause 3 (Lords Report Stage) https://bills.parliament.uk/bills/4030/stages/21281/amendments/10040760

6 All statutory functions under clause 3(1)(a)-(g) are eligible, by virtue of clause 3(5).

7 An amendment was tabled to the Lords Committee stage to repeal the 2024 Act and debated on the fifth day. The minister did not correct this, implying it would stay in place. House of Lords Committee, Day Five transcript (19 Oct 2026), Columns 159-160 https://hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2026-10-19/debates/20D8862D-044B-4CF7-8EE0-3CD6E8D24103/RailwaysBill

8 Misleading statements were made by the Rail Minister on Day 1 of Committee regarding GBR companies’ subsidiary status, claiming that joint ventures in property development would not be possible without this. On Day 2, a correction was requested on the record but the minister did not correct this either in the Committee or in later correspondence. House of Lords Committee, Day 1 transcript, Columns 204 – 213 (8 Sep 2026) https://hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2026-09-08/debates/1D3467A7-AF0D-4B77-A216-31E41F3431F7/RailwaysBill House of Lords Committee, Day 2 Transcript (10 Sep 2026), Columns 281, 307, 314 https://hansard.parliament.uk/lords/2026-09-10/debates/001F3228-80AC-406C-92A5-76C5DD6D656D/RailwaysBill ; Rail Minister’s Letter to Conservative peers (15 Sep 2026) https://data.parliament.uk/DepositedPapers/Files/DEP2026-0579/Lord_Hendy_Letter_on_Subsidiaries_for_the_library.docx
9 Clause 1(2),(3)

10 Train operators will have to be legally separate companies due to the Bill’s failure to repeal Regulations 14.9 and 19.4 of the Railways (Access, Management and Licensing of Railway Undertakings) Regulations 2016, which require full legal separation of operators from the body responsible for access and charging decisions. It follows that infrastructure managers will also need to be legally separate, since this would then become the only way to bring track and train together. This outcome is evident in the regional alliances set up for Southeastern, Southwestern and Greater Anglia so far.

The GBR parent company is set to be responsible for strategy, timetabling and financial auditing, with all other functions potentially being performed by separate companies. DfT, Response to GBR consultation (2025), p 15 https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6912f60dcf24e9250d893ef4/a-railway-fit-for-britains-future-Government-response-print-web-accessible.pdf

11 Network Rail's 2025-26 accounts (p 201-204) show that joint ventures with private companies are separately accounted for within its wholly owned subsidiary, Platform 4. The flexibility of this model can be seen by the fact that, in several cases, Network Rail's stake in property developments is as low as 33%. https://www.networkrail.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/Network-Rail-Annual-Report-and-Accounts-2026.pdf

12 See note 5

13 See note 3. This issue was previously raised in the House of Commons by Richard Burgon MP, who referred to the rail minister’s ‘commitment’ to bring in further changes regarding designation powers ‘to ensure that they cannot be used for back-door privatisation.’ Railways Bill Report Stage and Third Reading (10 June 2026) transcript https://www.parallelparliament.co.uk/debate/2026-06-10/commons/commons-chamber/railways-bill

In the Lords Committee, the definition of ‘designation’ was extensively queried by peers, demonstrating the need for clearer drafting and explanations. House of Lords Committee, Day 5 transcript (19 Oct 2026), Columns 152 – 165 https://hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2026-10-19/debates/20D8862D-044B-4CF7-8EE0-3CD6E8D24103/RailwaysBill

14 Clauses 25(1); 31(1)

15 Clause 30

16 EHRC, Response to the Transport Committee’s Railways Bill inquiry (Dec 2025) https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/our-work/advising-parliament-and-Governments/transport-committees-railway-bill-inquiry-our-response

Share this page