Probation should help the public, not profit

Probation services are responsible for the rehabilitation of offenders once they are released from prison, working to reduce reoffending rates and maintain public safety. 

However, in 2015 the then Justice Secretary Chris Grayling pushed through the sell-off of 70% of this long time public service – the most extensive privatisation in the criminal justice system ever.

 

As a result, ill-considered and reckless moves towards privatisation have jeopardised the quality of probation work - which have worsened accountability, stretched workers and increased dangers to public safety.

What you need to know

In June 2014, the Conservative government announced its plan to ‘revolutionise’ the probation service. 35 publicly owned, self governing regional probation services were split up and sold off.
 
Probation is now split into two tiers:
  • 70% of cases are low risk offenders, dealt with by 21 ‘Community Rehabilitation Companies’ (CRCs). These companies are tendered out to private organisations and are responsible for probation across a region of the country.
  • 30% of cases are high risk offenders, which are all dealt with by our public National Probation Service.
In 2017, the government changed the terms of the CRC contracts, handing out more money to the private contractors, because of ‘unforeseen challenges’ that the contractors had faced. The National Audit Office investigated these changes and found that the CRCs had underperformed, and been rewarded with a pay rise. 
 
The taxpayer has taken the strain of this extra payment, once again shouldering the risk of providing public services, while private companies pocket the profit.
 

What are the effects of privatisation?

Probation services were working well under public ownership: In 2013 the Ministry of Justice rated all 35 publicly owned probation trusts in England and Wales as good or excellent. But despite this, the services were privatised in 2015 without pilot schemes and in the face of widespread opposition.

In 2017, HM Inspectorate of Probation found that  the NPS was protecting the public well, but that the private CRCs were failing in half of cases.

PRIVATE PROFITS OVER PUBLIC SAFETY

Conflicting interests - between public service and profit motives - also threaten public safety. Since privatisation, the number of convicts committing a serious further offence while under probation supervision has risen 20%.

CRCs are failing to meet 2/3rds of their targets on average - with the worst performing company only meeting 4 out of 24 target measures. These failures are a risk to the safety of the public and staff as well as the wellbeing and future of the offenders.

WORSE WORKING CONDITIONS AND LOWER STAFF MORALE

A report released in 2016 by Dr. Gill Kirton, which surveyed staff in CRCs, demonstrated that many staff have expressed concerns about increasing risks to their safety in working conditions. Since the sell-off, for example, working practices have become more isolated. Alongside this, open-plan offices have been introduced in many of the centres, meaning that probation officers often have to conduct sensitive interviews with offenders in front of their colleagues.

Union surveys show more than half of those working for private firms in the probation sector are now looking for new employment.

STRETCHED NATIONAL PROBATION SERVICE

Kirton’s report also discusses the impact of privatisation on the National Probation Service, which is still publicly owned. Now left to deal only with high-risk and harrowing cases, increasing levels of stress and mental health problems have been reported among staff – who used to have more of a balanced caseload.

Anonymous NPS worker: “I am concerned about my physical health … as well as my mental health. I have come back after two weeks off sick because I was concerned for my colleagues who are already in a very small team and were having to cover my cases in my absence. I did not return because I felt better.”

Staff of CRCs are also feeling the pressure. Sodexo announced huge staff cuts barely months after privatisation, meaning that the remaining staff are dealing with an unmanageable workload. Some junior officers in CRCs are now handling more than 200 cases each, despite 60 cases being the maximum it is recommended to handle safely.

What can you do?

Join 30,000 people demanding public ownership

Help us win campaigns by subscribing to our mailing list! We'll hold your data in accordance with our privacy policy and send you carefully chosen information about current and future campaigns, projects and appeals. You can unsubscribe at any time.