Tell us what you think

Woman with megaphone in a crowd

Why do you want to see public services run for people not profit? Tell us your story here.

We'll use your comments to help make the case for public ownership - look out for your thoughts on our homepage!

Thanks for telling us what you think.

Photo used under Creative Commons licensing, thanks to anw.fr.

Comments

Mike replied on Permalink

While I personally agree with a vast majority of arguments against privatisation of UK's public services while at the same time improving the level of efficiency of management of these and reducing the waste of public money, I also believe that only essential public services should remain public which includes infrastructure, health and education.

To go even further, most if not all already privatised public services should be reverted back to become public, including for example trains, communication infrastructure and care for people with learning disabilities.

Having said that, television including Channel 4 and BBC do not count as essential public services with the exception of parts of BBC responsible for education, culture (in educational sense) and information (BBC News) mission. Please do not push for these to remain public as we are talking about taxpayers money spent on entertainment programs at the benefit of people watching these but at the expense of everyone else.

Kate replied on Permalink

We believe that public services paid for by the public should not be sold. People have a different view on what is essential and what is not. Channel 4 does ground breaking work, doesn't cost the tax payer a penny and contributes to our economy.

Best wishes Kate and the We Own It team.

pauline colledge replied on Permalink

I didn't send letter because this is Islington North,they know. Every time there is a gov reorg of the NHS eg. 2012 they are sneakily bringing it ever closer to a US model. I bet the money they profess to spend on NHS is also used to build and establish an ever increasing number of private facilities. Is this a losing battle.?. The Euroean model where the state runs non profit insurane scheme with built-in protections worth studying. Campaigning for this could achieve more and alarm a profiteering greedy govt. Campaigning for something rather than reacting and never catching up with gov's machinations.

I am partially sighted

Steffy Cairns replied on Permalink

There's no excuse for privatisation, as there's absolutley no fat left to be cut off from services such as the NHS. The privatisation movement is very covert. As far back as 2015, letters to our local social services were sent to ' the People Group ', but no - one could tell me who they were?

The ' levelling up agenda ' is farcical, when services are increasingly being put into private hands, so that the lowest paid workers receive even less. eg. Lab workers in private testing cos. compared to NHS. Have you seen what the Directors of CareUk receive in remuneration? It's sickening!

Steven Corcoran replied on Permalink

It's much worse

“Capital must protect itself in every possible way, both by combination and legislation.   Debts must be collected, mortgages foreclosed as rapidly as possible.  When, through process of law, the common people lose their homes, they will become more docile and more easily governed through the strong arm of the government applied by a central power of wealth under leading financiers.   These truths are well known among our principal men, who are now engaged in forming an imperialism to govern the world.   By dividing the voter through the political party system, we can get them to expend their energies in fighting for questions of no importance.   It is thus, by discrete action, we can secure for ourselves that which has been so well planned and so successfully accomplished.”

Montagu Norman – Governor of the Bank of England – addressing the United States Bankers’ Association, New York City, 1924

Scary

Graham blake replied on Permalink

Sexual health (GUM) clinics now operated by serco, tht et al . Profits out of nhs to serco mostly. This applies to east of england. Should be back to full nhs cover

Eddie Dougall replied on Permalink

You say "privatisation is not wrong per se", well it is when applied to strategic requirements of the UK nationally, or people individually, in terms of services/goods essential to life. I never imagined that water, energy, rail, housing (selling off of council houses), health care would ever be privatised, I thought the public would not stand for it. However offer shares at a low enough price, or houses at about half price or so, and thoughts of the future consequences were ignored. Very sad what people can be bribed to do.

James Nicholson replied on Permalink

A long overdue review of offshore tax havens should be undertaken to prevent the very wealthy domiciled in this country from paying their UK taxes. Clearly not an action for a Selfservative government, but for a meaningful polical opposition - if we have one.

Devinder singh replied on Permalink

All energy companies must be under UK government so that it should be make as cheaper and the profits should go the government not into the private hands.....thanks.

Dermot Killingley replied on Permalink

Government incompetence isn't an accident, it's part of Tory ideology. To maintain the fiction that the market yields the best outcomes, the government has to show itself to be both inefficient and lacking in benevolence.

Lynn replied on Permalink

It's time that the public had a say in energy suppliers and our water companies

Patricia Simpson replied on Permalink

My GP surgery has been taken over by a private company, you can’t get appointments (you can’t even get someone to answer the phone), everything is prioritised by money and services have been steadily reduced. Dental services have been decimated and our local hospital has been rendered impotent nearly leading to the death of my son. It’s time to halt the rot.

Eddie Dougall replied on Permalink

Same goes for 'Academy' schools, with US and other interests collecting together groups of them and giving megabucks to the new-style CEO who has absolute control of where the money goes that the schools get from government. Piecemeal

privatisation.

Geoff Clarkson replied on Permalink

An animated fairy I have just made tale about how privatised water is polluting our rivers.

STINKY STORY https://vimeo.com/664337462

Colin Bennett replied on Permalink

I am fully in agreement about public services being run for the good of the country rather than for private profit.

I would, however, stipulate that they should be run independently of micro-management by any Government and not interfered with for political advantage.

Any Government should only be allowed to make general guidance as to the way the service is run.

Sarah Dent replied on Permalink

Private companies equate 'cost saving' with efficiency. Even if a service is ostensibly cheaper - eg hospital cleaners - it is not efficient to employ people on wages which are so low they need in-work benefits to top up their earnings. This is a ridiculous and if the cost of providing the benefits - administration and payments - were added to the cost of the service, I bet it would be seen to be what it is. An expensive and hugely inefficient way to divert taxpayers' money into the hands of corporate profiteers, and increase inequality.

Maryan Hadley replied on Permalink

These shysters would sell off their own children. Absolutely devoid of integrity.

Adam Hiley replied on Permalink

I implore my fellow Britons to wake up about this government and this Lame Prime Minister and remove them from office forget Labour Starmer will offer no alternative to this rogue Government the NHS deserves to be fully funded now We are over the worst of covid19 the NHS must never be run down by severe funding cuts by Labour or the Tories ever again Johnson has no respect for the British public he must go now

Sue Longrigg replied on Permalink

Thank you for the presentation today. It was clear and easy to follow. In principle I agree with nationalisation and socialism. I live in Wales where the only water supplier available in Welsh Water who claim to be a not for profit organisation however the prices are still high and we still have a big sewerage discharge problem. Obviously there is some kind of corruption going on and I think you would strengthen your case if you could point to this as one of the possible dangers of nationalisation and explain measures that could be put in place to root this out.

Jacqueline Savill replied on Permalink

I believe that the opposition parties in H of C should be campaigning now on saving certain services completely in the NHS from privatisation. This will bring the matter to public attention and make them realise there is a problem. (Even the most self centre journalists use them!)

I would start with campaigning on the specialist children and cancer hospitals, organ donation, blood donation, the ambulance service and antenatal and obstetric care. If people realised what was at stake they might be more responsive to listening.

John Harries - ... replied on Permalink

Hi. To be paying the same amount,. We must all be taxed. 1 percent of our earnings. NO OPT OUT BY THE WEALTHIEST.

Laureen Sherry replied on Permalink

The NHS should not be a marketplace. Health should be on the basis of need. There is already a two-tier system.

Paul Flynn replied on Permalink

I believe in public ownership for all utilities, buses, trains, NHS etc

My only proviso is that union power should be partially curtailed by law to prevent the excesses of the 70s

Alan Digweed replied on Permalink

Privatisation of the bus services was and is a myth. The Government, well tax payers spend millions each year on subsidizing the services in the form of fuel duty rebates (FDR). Council. already struggling with austerity subsidize oerators to run non commercial services. The big operators have no interest in providing a service but only in generating profit, profits which could belong in the public purse and not the shareholders

maurice clive bisby replied on Permalink

1. Wonderful that you exist.

2. Glad to discover you.

3. Disgusted with uk political corruption I joined the throng exiting Britain last year. I think that if you target British Expats in the EU, like me, you will gain further support.

We are still entitled to vote in UK national elections..... M

Anon replied on Permalink

I used to work for an NHS funded private service. It was disturbing, with many abusing their position for financial gain. The system gave financial reward for good service, reporting 'green' for mental health wards for women and children. The factor of finance lead to misreporting incidents and business-minded management. Mental health declined in staff and lead to closure by 'nhs england' only to continue with limited training and a change of ward type. Staff requested to leave for abuse were moved to other hospitals. Agency staff were reported to have using a false identity for DBS and passport ID. CAMHS Psychiatrists penalised for over-prescription of medication were transferred to lead other larger hospital wards.

I left indefinitely after googling the human rights of children, not able to participate in a system that would entail that doubt I have found this campaign, and now have somewhere to commit my anger.

We cannot let corporate crawlers take our NHS.

Adam Fuller replied on Permalink

Because I get the bus to my local swimming pool for much needed exercise I have to put profit into other peoples pockets. I'd like to do it more often but can't because the shareholders (who can afford all the exercise in the world) need more profit. The cost of getting into the swimming pool for one hour for myself is £4.60! It's only a 25 metre lane pool. How much of that is for the shareholders

Pete replied on Permalink

My son needed his ears syringing. Now apparently this is not available on NHS and had got to be done by a private clinic. Privatisation is on its way. Shame on you Boris. But I’m sure you cronies in the private sector will do nicely out of it. Greed Greed Greed.

Maria Sophia Quine replied on Permalink

I am an historian of public welfare and modern states. The ‘battle’ to build welfare-states which enshrine the rights of individuals to basic rights of security and protection in poverty, old-age, and sickness took centuries. In this country, the outcome was one of the greatest achievements of the modern period - a free and universal National Health Service delivering care to all, without regard to income. We are by stealth and secrecy losing our NHS as private companies colonise it for profit. To go further down the American path would be truly epic and disastrous for all.

Heather Jane Fl... replied on Permalink

I was born in 1948, and as a very young child I was seriously ill, and needed hospital care. The NHS saved my life. Many of my family worked in the NHS, as I did for more than 35 years.

Having a health service that is free and non-discriminating is a basic HUMAN RIGHT, and whilst I have no objection to people seeking private medical care if they wish, it would be devastating if the NHS was privatised by profiteers.

Ms Frances Potter replied on Permalink

I was in hospital with a broken hip at Christmas 2020. It was awful, Covid was rampant, after 2 days visitors were banned. We were alone with the staff... Everyone from the tea ladies upwards were worked to the bone. There was little time for nurses to socialise and because the staff were stretched to breaking point, patients were sometimes ignored for longer than was comfortable. Wearing masks made communications difficult, particularly for the seriously ill, elderly, deaf or demented. Jobs have been split up so that some of the people who make the frequent temp, blood pressure, sugar etc tests, have no authority and were so busy keeping track of their tasks, that they have no time to find someone with authority and pass on any patients requests or queries. These tests are the very important monitoring of patient progress or decline. And I was shocked to find out these important people were being paid below the living wage!

Many staff were off sick with Covid, the nurses said most of them had had it already, and were still experiencing side effects such as loss of sense of smell many weeks after, and exhaustion. I was unable to have physio in the usual room set aside for it, as the hospital was so full that that room had very poorly people in it. Gradually Covid came closer and closer as each ward in turn got the infection. I was discharged in a hurry. not soon enough it turned out to prevent me bringing Covid home and giving it to my partner and youngest son and his wife. Some weeks later I found out that a lovely lady i had made friends with, also a broken hip patient, 91 BUT with all her marbles, also got Covid. After 2 weeks they sent her home. She lived alone. There was no adequate care package available. She died.

I haven't even mentioned the torn bed curtains, the lack of spare pillows, the atmosphere of panic and fear amongst the staff...

Lack of funding over years of neglect has led to a shortage of nursing staff, staff becoming victims of the pandemic due to lack of PPE, the toilets needing serious upgrading and modernisation...

Tony replied on Permalink

I fully agree with a lot on here but I disagree about the BBC they are a hidden tax. We have to pay for it if we want to or not and the fat cats running it have no desire to help the public, just get rich themselves all taking out what they can get hold of. If the wages and expenditure was properly managed then there would be plenty of money in there and OAP's over 75 would still be able to have a free licence so get that right and I will support this if not then let it disappear.

DR G A RICHMOND replied on Permalink

I am a retired GP having worked all my life in the NHS. General Practice was perfect, with patients and doctor getting to know each other. Many night calls were resolved over the phone, as the doctor was often familiar to the caller and aware of their problems. All that was needed was friendly reassurance and an agreement to see that the next day at the surgery if that were needed. The ambulance programmes on TV show how important the personal touch can be and how easily many problems are solved by face to face contact. The idea of diluting the role of general practice is abhorrent. Replacing the role of general practice by an army of paid telephone advisors is absurd. G.P's PROVIDE A FRIENDLY PERSONAL SERVICE THAT CANNOT BE REPLACED by a commercial army of computer algorithms.

William Coleman replied on Permalink

I do not know how it was allowed to get to this state . We do not want our much valued NHS to be a cash cow for bussiness' to profit from people's unfortunate illness. I have recently taken my bank account from Virginia Money due to their expansionist plans . No private companies should be allowed on this board.just patients or the likes

AnnM replied on Permalink

It is becoming increasingly evident that wealth and privilege gets too many people more than they deserve. This is at the expense of the country, its people and society. Inequality is increasing and it is the poorest and most disadvantaged that always suffer the most as a result. All our public services are underfunded and no longer merit their name! We waste potential in our youth, with a drastically underfunded education system for the majority of students and do not reward or respect those that serve us the most, like care workers, doctors and nurses in the NHS and teachers.

I used to be proud to live in this country.

Now I despair.I have to constantly fight for funding for disabled members of my family against a DWP with no heart, humanity or honesty. Everything is a battle. A lifetime of constant fighting for diagnosis, support and understanding and again respect. Social workers are overwhelmed. The mental health services are on their knees. We all deserve a decent quality of life wharever our circumstances.

Neil Dawson replied on Permalink

Private companies should not be allowed to sit on decision making committees or boards as they have a self interest and will work for that self interest. It is very important that the users of these services should be represented!

Mel Dickson replied on Permalink

I Demand that private companies should not be allowed to sit on NHS decision-making bodies because they care more about profits than they do about making sure people are well cared for.

And, I demand that patients and the public should be given a seat on key decision-making committees and boards because patient voices are important for designing services that work for everyone.

John Woffinden replied on Permalink

The NHS is for the patients not for companies making profits

ken kirk replied on Permalink

Privatisation of the NHS has been a disaster. Thanks to Lansley's 2012 H&SC Act private companies have been able to cherry pick the services they want and leave the unprofitable ones to the publicly run NHS. In running privatised services it's clear that profit has been their prime objective, but the service they offer has been a catastrophe. Check out https://www.nhsforsale.info/contract-failure/50-examples-of-nhs-outsourcing-failures/

Fred Groves replied on Permalink

Profit has no place in the NHS. We demand equality of treatment regardless of wealth and the patients who after all pay for the service deserve a say in the decisions. Certainly organisations who will potentially profit from those decisions should be excluded. We should never take for granted what a treasure we have in the NHS and guard it against anyone who wants to destroy it.

Ronald Ferguson replied on Permalink

~The NHS was introduced following world war 2 as ordinary men and women who had served through it demanded a better society, not just one run for the rich and powerful. It therefore belongs to the people of this country and not to the government to be sold off to their friends and ilk. The government's job is to run it efficiently, not for profit. Health is a basic human need. Ill health is often related to poverty, poor housing, stress, lack of opportunity, the need to be heard and have some control over how our lives are lived. This is dependent on how we organise society. Health is the responsibility of all of us and should therefore be free and available to all, whatever your income or status. It should never be run for profit..

Alan Wood replied on Permalink

Our health service is deteriorating fast. It seems that this government is hell bent on privatising Our National Health Service by stealth and graduating steps. This will not benefit the NHS user but make profits for large companies. Enough is enough and accordingly:-

I do not wish that PRIVATE COMPANIES SHOULD NOT BE ALLOWED TO SIT ON NHS

DECISION-MAKING BODIES because they care more about profits than they do

about making sure people are well cared for.

I also wish that PATIENTS AND THE PUBLIC SHOULD BE GIVEN A SEAT ON KEY

DECISION-MAKING COMMITTEES AND BOARDS because patient voices are important

for designing services that work for everyone.

richard beswick replied on Permalink

The NHS is one of the few public services that the Tories have not yet managed to take out of our hands and pass to the avaricious private sector, often to the benefit of their associates and to the great detriment of the voting public. So far all the privatized operations have been most unsuccessful, no investment and only resulting in the public paying more for a reduced and inferior service.

It would be one of the greatest tragedies if these self serving Tories are allowed to ruin the little we have left. THEY MUST BE STOPPED, otherwise hello to the failed United States model, God help us all.

Dale replied on Permalink

I have now ereached an age where my body is starting to break down. Aches and pains I can tolerate, but when they can be fixed with a quick op that I don't even have to stay overnight for, I get angry that I have to wait half a lifetime to get it. Depite being in serious pain every day and relying on high powered painkillers, that are only supposed to be a short term temporary solution, I have had no reply from the hospital scheduling after over 4 weeks of waiting and that's just to find out when the appointment to have the op is. Chances are, when I do get the letter telling me when the appointment is, I'll be waiting another year or two in seriouos pain before I get the actual op done.

NHS is seriously screwed up right now and it has nothing to do with Brexit and everything to do with gross underfunding, privatisation, along with overpopulation by mass immigration as well as asylum seekers taking all the primary appointment slots when they have not paid a penny toward it. I have paid my NI stamp since I started working in the 70's, now I need the service I paid so much for, I expect to get it. If I wanted to go private, I would have taken out BUPA insurance.

Pat Ruaune replied on Permalink

At age 81 I cannot tolerate what is happening under this government. My daughter, a psychiatric nurse is really depressed by the underfunding in her area of the NHS. She predicts a great deal more pu lic danger as well as to "her" very sick patients who are gradually being recategorised as responsible when they are very ill. She had to browband an ENT hospital doctor during a "telephone appointment" with my husband, who could not hear anything and was in agony with a serious ear infection, to gain a hospital appointment. This resulted in emergency treatment. I have many more examples.

Hohn replied on Permalink

Private Health Insurance creates levels of Society by wealth. Meaning only the rich can survive. It will be the end of the British way of life.

richard beswick replied on Permalink

Regrettably that has already occurred and been cemented by the idiotic people who gave this self serving and incompetent Tory the mandate to ruin us.

Oliver Swingler replied on Permalink

Do you have an up-to-date list of Tory Ministers (and MPs) with links to private healthcare companies and funding banks - or perhaps pen portraits (like the memes Rachael Swindon did) which can be widely publicised?

Lorraine Leigh replied on Permalink

Not only the NHS, but the government is trying to privatise Channel 4 now…. Yet they are self-funding….this authoritarian, abhorrent and controlling government is treating us as if they are the Chinese government and we Britons are from Hong-Kong…. No true freedoms…. Also down with the one-sided GB News. Andrew Neil? I never thought he’d disgrace himself so…..

Adam Hiley replied on Permalink

If we want decent public services, military and freedoms then get rid of this abomination of a government it's compliant opposition parties and lame stream media there is no way Johnson should remain in office a day longer he's a embarrassment to Britain and I personally would feel safer without him Hancock gove Patel and Sage around

Pages

Add new comment

Copy link