Stop the NHS White Paper that promises further privatisation

18 March 2021

Stop the NHS White Paper that promises further privatisation

It’s time to reinstate our NHS as a fully public service. Profit has no place in our NHS. The Health and Social Care Committee’s inquiry on the Department’s White Paper on Health and Social care closes on Tuesday 23rd. We think it's really crucial that thousands of people respond to this inquiry, saying why you think this White Paper should be withdrawn! Here's how to!

1) Go to the 'call for evidence' heremaking sure to say you're 'an individual'. They'll ask for a few details first before asking you to upload a file.

2) Upload this word file (odt version here), add personal thoughts or further information if you want, and then submit! You're done - thank you so much.

 

Want more information, or to personalise your response?

Here are some key reasons why the White Paper are bad news for OUR NHS in England (and for all the UK long-term)

In 2021, Matt Hancock and Boris Johnson have promised to bring in legislation that will hand over the current organisation of NHS regions to something called 'Integrated Care Systems'. These plans will lead to more of our health services being handed over to private companies. But how?

  • These new bodies will commission health services for an area, but they could have private companies sitting on their boards.  The bodies have been criticised for encouraging under treatment or rationing of services, as members of the board (which could include private companies) will get to keep any money they don't spend, and they will bring an area under tight financial controlsAll of this sounds familiar right? More private involvement, more contracts to private companies and less funding for the NHS to look after people so that they need other, private options.
  • It will open the door to more cronyism -  yet more contracts would be given to government pals like Serco, as we’ve seen in the pandemic, but without any competition - that’s what the government means by ‘reducing bureaucracy’. 
  • While key experts say there will be a reduction of 'accountability and democratic oversight' over our NHS, what's even more concrete and worrying for some is that there is discussion of 'sharing' the 'rewards' with private companies. This means money that could be spent on health services will be leaked as profits to private companies.  

Want to read more about this?

Keep Our NHS Public have been keeping on top of these developments for years. Here is their campaign page with some great briefings you can read. This is a great summary to start with from Allyson Pollock and Peter Roderick (co-authors of the NHS Reinstatement Bill).

Do you believe in public services for people not profit?

Win campaigns for public ownership by subscribing to our mailing list! We'll hold your data in accordance with our privacy policy and send you carefully chosen information about current and future campaigns, projects and appeals. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Comments

Peter Jenkins replied on Permalink

We own the NHS and it is NOT FOR SALE

Jo Smith Finley replied on Permalink

Our NHS must never be exploited for private profit. It must always be properly funded and free at the point of use for people from all social classes.

Mrs Gillian Hind replied on Permalink

I am writing to ask you not to continue with the white paper which would change the current organisation of NHS regions to an 'Integrated Care Systems'. These plans will lead to more of our health services being handed over to private companies. All the organisation of the NHS should be run by the NHS and any profits should go back into the system and not to private companies.

Yours

Gillian Hind

Mike Cundell replied on Permalink

No privatisation in the NHS. Full stop

David Woods replied on Permalink

If you go down this road where will it stop?

Chris Bullen replied on Permalink

It is not appropriate or morally defensible to make a profit from people's health misfortunes. Many of us have been paying tax and national insurance contribution (as did our parents and grandparents)naively believing that we would receive "free health care" from birth to death.

Martin Marley replied on Permalink

The NHS must not be under the control of private companies or individuals. This power and control would soon be Abused ,WE All KNOW THAT IT WILL HAPPEN

Gillian Mathie replied on Permalink

The NHS should be funded publicly and able to put the care of patients first without being asset-stripped, having services cut in the interests of profit for private companies and their share-holders. The NHS was a national organisation and we have seen in the past few years the damage done to those elements that have been privatised e.g mental health services put out to private companies in some areas of the country, GP surgeries sold to private companies e.g. Centene and then sold. We have also seen the outstanding work of the NHS and its professionals this past year in marked contrast to the profilgate squandering of private companies which failed in their contractual obligations to provide the service with suitable equipment e.g. PPE. Leave the NHS to those professionals who understand medicine and do not hand it over to accountants and private profiteers.

Richard Stakes replied on Permalink

Me the US health system out of the UK. The US system is not worthy of a civilised country in the 21st century.

Sheila Chambers replied on Permalink

We must protest against this American take-over. We do not want privatisation.

Gordon Legg replied on Permalink

Now is not the time to privatise the NHS. Do not destroy our most precious asset. We will never forget or forgive you, if you proceed with this unnecessary action.

Stewart Taylor replied on Permalink

The NHS is our greatest public service, it needs proper funding not privatisation.

Anonymous replied on Permalink

This paper is a treasonable act. Hands off our property.

Kathryn Gale replied on Permalink

Private health insurance has a role to play but NHS medical and dental care should be free

richard carder replied on Permalink

No one should be making a profit from healthcare, which should be free for all patients, as it was in the beginning of the NHS. The profit motive corrupts the concept of healthcare !

CHRISTINE PARKER replied on Permalink

Repeal the H&SCA and Reinstate our NHS, with the NHS Bill,

Sharon Knight replied on Permalink

The government said the NHS is not for sale. The NHS is about people and not profit and must remain a public service.

Mrs wendy newton replied on Permalink

Stop trying to sell our NHS

Anita Darnell replied on Permalink

A person’s health must not depend on their wealth. Please stop this White Paper.

Evelyn replied on Permalink

The NHS is not for sale full stop! No to the white paper

Michael Harker Tait replied on Permalink

Awful that pushing for health service to be run for profit

Will inevitably lead to rich elite being served and poor ignored

OBSCENE

John Light replied on Permalink

This will result in more monet taken from my income as tax being handed over to shareholders who teally do nothing to improve my healtha nd that of my family without any control by me. I refuse to countenance that and will not vote for politicians who allow it. They do not represent me.

Nigel Bilson replied on Permalink

The nhs must remain free at point of service and should not be privatised!!

Shirley A McCarthy replied on Permalink

As a retired NHS Senior Manager, I have witnessed first-hand how privatised services bring

a) a lack of accountability as big corporations have the lawyers and accountants to outsmart the ever-stretched public service, resulting in cherry-picking of contracted work, no rcourse if contract prove untenable and tenuous or non-existent accountability due to claims of 'commercial - in confidence

b) proliferation, overlap and the waste of resources required to co-ordinate and account for non-standard ranges and differences in provision

Sonia Hollywood replied on Permalink

Action needed now!

Alan wright replied on Permalink

Health should not be for profit.

Phil Luke replied on Permalink

This government is hell-bent on privatisation, no doubt with a pocket-lining intent.

Mitchell A Mccarthy replied on Permalink

I'd like to help any way I can to make sure that families, communities, economy and the environment get the justice that they deserve.

Esther Sullivan replied on Permalink

"Selling off" our NHS will render Britian's world-class, essential social service, the envy of the whole world, the end of the N.H.S.!

Linda Stevenson replied on Permalink

We must stop this white paper bill.NHS is ours keep it that way.we don't want people running it for profit.keep it public.The public care about people not about profit.Hands of our NHS

Anonymous replied on Permalink

There is no place for profit making in health care

Rowena O’Toole replied on Permalink

Please stop pretending to appreciate the NHS, selling GP surgeries to Centeme and stop trying to privatise the NHS that has served us all so brilliantly throughout the pandemic, even caring for the Prime Minister.

It is an insult to democracy and the memory of Captain Sir Tom Moore to pursue this White Paper!

Jeffrey Allen replied on Permalink

We don't need American style health don't care in this couentry. We get ripped off enough already, how about our so called government looking after the best interests of the people of the UK and not climbing into bed with companies who only have profit and self interest at heart.

Maria English replied on Permalink

Mr Johnson you promised more money for the NHS when we came out of Europe We the people expect you to keep your promise and no privatisation of our Nation Health Service

Tony Miller replied on Permalink

The NHS was started to make sure everyone had free healthcare, now it will be farmed out to private companies, mainly American companies, these companies will cherry pick what illnesses they will treat. The running costs of all health treatments will rise, this will then reflect on the service provided, just like the railways and the utility companies. Terrible services that are expensive.

Anne Khan replied on Permalink

Another nail in the U.K. citizens coffins, should the government sign up to American Health Conglomerates ... One only has to look at the dire state of health care, emergency health care, hospitalisation, operations etc in US health care system today, sooooo many cannot afford the health care insurance payments to cover medical bills or prescription costs etc ... we MOST CERTAINLY DO NOT WANT U.S. HEALTH INSURANCE GROUPS/HEALTH CARE CONGLOMERATES FLEECING US WHILST WE NEED POSSIBLE SERIOUS OPS/MEDICAL CARE .. this white paper is a BIG FAT NO from me ....

Manda Kaye replied on Permalink

The NHS belongs to us (The People) and we (The People) run and manage it for us and only us and we do not believe in profits as profits hurt and even kill people! So Hands Off!

Sarah Laue replied on Permalink

The NHS choices is a previous service that must remain in public hands,for people not profit.

April Cummins replied on Permalink

Having worked the NHS in the 70's when the beginning of privatisation began. It was chaotic, setting departments against one another for meds and dressings. The cleaning of the hospital was extraordinarily below standard and we were told to consider patients not as patients but clients. We were given talks on how to address 'clients'. It felt as though we were being trained to sell goods in a department store. Now the government who praise the NHS on one hand are preparing to invite private businesses to take over the health of all of the country. Despicable and atrocious.

Jacobus Pretorius replied on Permalink

I stand absolutely behind the We Own It campaign's response to this white paper. I am not an economist or an active campaigner with all the facts at my fingertips, but I have first hand experience of (some of) the effects of the current state of privatisation of the NHS; to have to wait months and months for a simple procedure (a hernia repair) to be done is frustrating and crazy. I am aware that the privatisation of the NHS has been going for many many years; it is being sneaked into the British people's lives extremely cleverly and may be sold to the public as getting some "efficiency" into the NHS, but it is in reality a slow-motion train crash. I guess that the real idea behind privatisation of the NHS is to take the health of the nation off the government's books, come what may. It is really a cousin of conservative governments' love of "austerity" or "balancing the books". It is definitely a cousin of the clever (slimy?) public finance initiative. What happens when the nation's health is left to the markets is (at least) two things: (1) poor people cannot get the health care they need, and (2) the private companies ("the market") can make money off those who can afford the private companies' tariffs. Making the health of the nation a matter for "the markets to sort out" resulted in the chaos we were in when Covid struck. If I look at the utter failure of spending 22 billion pounds (in one year!!!!!) on a track and trace system that did not work, and I then compare that with the amazing success of the country-wide vaccination process which I guess was driven largely by the NHS and volunteers from the public, I think there is really no comparison. I vote to stop the privatisation process in its tracks, and to reverse all the penny-wise-pound-foolish stuff that has happened to date.

Richard Eccles replied on Permalink

This bill is against everything you have said iun the recent Covid pandemic. Tories are liars, cheats, conmen, fraudsters and racists and Boris is the worst of them.

Yvonne Hill replied on Permalink

Need action now

Gerald Conrad Lewis replied on Permalink

It is about time the Government woke up to the fact that this our money and we do not want it waisted by giving it to US businesses or anyone else. We can look after our own affairs. We can manage on our own and not line other peoples pockets.

Shelley replied on Permalink

This was no where in your manifesto, the NHS belongs to the public tax payers not the private money makers!!!

Geraldine Cowan replied on Permalink

The NHS is the pride of Britain. This greedy, shortsighted, selfish government is not! SHAME ON YOU.

Kathleen Allen replied on Permalink

Stop this white paper it's immoral and a slap in the face for our NHS whose expertise and selfless service has saved mant lives while Government made o e blunder after the other and gave contracts to cronies for useless PPE and made a mess of test and trace.

Hilary Noculak replied on Permalink

Keep our NHS as a totally public service with NO private companies involved. The NHS is an important service for the general public, it is NOT for this government to sell it off piecemeal to private buyers.

Denny replied on Permalink

“ Our objective should be denationalising the provision of healthcare in Britain “ Jeremy Hunt ex Health Secretary.

The Tories have sold everything from British Telecoms to the Royal Mail, enough is enough..thie NHS is a life saving service, owned and paid for by the British public.

Deirdre replied on Permalink

We must keep it the NHS public. DO NOT GIVE IN.

Ann Newton-Marcial replied on Permalink

Stop privatisation of our NHS. Have the decency to consider the people of this country who own the NHS. I challenge you to conduct a referendum to seek permission for the privatisation. One question ‘can we sell off your NHS’ ? let’s see how much support you get.

Gloria Zentler-... replied on Permalink

The NHS MUST be kept in public hands, private company are interested in making money and the only way that can be done is by cutting services.

This White Paper Bill must be stopped if we want to keep the NHS for the public.

Reinhard Huss replied on Permalink

Private profit is an unnecessary cost for the public. I do not want my tax payment to be wasted on private profit.

Kate Chapman replied on Permalink

Action needs to be taken straight away

Kate Chapman replied on Permalink

Action needs to be taken straight away.

Kate Chapman replied on Permalink

The white paper bill has got to be stopped immediately

Jenny Templeton replied on Permalink

No to any private involvement in the nhs .The nhs should be a fully public service and not a profit making organisation !

Mandy Baldwin replied on Permalink

This government has repeatedly said they won't privatise our NHS. Were they telling lies? This is privatisation, which is outrageous and completely unacceptable after the year we've just been through, with no doubt more to come. They must be mad!

Please withdraw this whole idea and listen to the people you are supposed to represent!

Luisa Martin replied on Permalink

Disgraceful act by this government to do something that the country does not won’t , people have not voted to sell the NHS, so the government should not be allowed to to do this with out the consents of the British people!!

Hilary Flett replied on Permalink

The government’s role should be to use our taxes to ensure our NHS is properly funded and managed rather than reward private companies and their cronies for expensive and unworkable “solutions”. Most professionals would prefer to work for the NHS and are best placed to offer solutions to service problems, which should be sought and then considered by NHS management.

Shane Helsby replied on Permalink

People’s health is more important than profits this needs to stop

Mohammed Rashid replied on Permalink

NHS for the people

M v Stoll replied on Permalink

Stop this white paper it is dangerous to our NHS, we want NO private or for profit companies involved in OUR NHS.

Nial Pickering replied on Permalink

The NHS and the people of the UK deserve better than this after the pandemic and years of austerity! NO to privitisation of the NHS

Lindsay Hodgson replied on Permalink

The NHS should not be treated as a profit making business. Healthcare should be a basic human right. Privatisation will just increase the divide between the rich and the poor. We must not allow privatisation of the NHS - it is NOT for sale

Glenys Timson replied on Permalink

Our NHS is NOT for sale. It belongs to the people of this country. I remember when the NHS came into being. People queued outside the doctor's just to see if it was real because they couldn't believe that they didn't have to be afraid to be ill any more - however they do now though don't they! Our health service used to be the envy of the world! We do NOT WANT AMERiCAN STYLE health care here we want our health service in THE PUBLIC SECTOR and properly FUNDED!!

Jeremy Bell replied on Permalink

You promised that the NHS would be safe in your hands...selling it off is wrong!

Amanda Caroline... replied on Permalink

The NHS should not be up for sale!

Anne Amison replied on Permalink

Keep the NHS in public hands - put people before profit!

Dominique Hudson replied on Permalink

For a better healthcare , keep our NHS in public hands

Liza replied on Permalink

Stop the white paper bill immediately

Frances Bell replied on Permalink

The bit that works during this epidemic is the NHS. Our economy has taken a big hit. There is another epidemic due every decade or less and will do the same damage. We will repeat the damage unless we strengthen the parts that worked this time (NHS and hospitals) and stop promoting the bits that failed and cost tens of thousands of lives and loss to the economy.

Jacky Apps replied on Permalink

The NHS must be protected from privatization you cannot put a price on health its dangerous the white paper bill must be withdrawn

Susan Thornton replied on Permalink

Our NHS belongs to us

Free at the point of need

Not for profit

Wesley George Brown replied on Permalink

More money for Conservative party associates means less for front line services. Do not allow this bill to proceed.

Vickie Benson replied on Permalink

Stop this white paper now..

Paul Garner replied on Permalink

Bring our NHS back into 100% public ownership

Carola Haigh replied on Permalink

This increasing privatisation leads to profits going into private hands rather than remaining in the. Health Service.

David Carter replied on Permalink

I was a career railway man. I saw from the inside the Tory’s modus operandi for privatisation. Chip away from the edges, reduce funding, demoralised staff, finally break up into smaller units to enable a sell off. This results in big payments for the few at the top, destruction of career for many.

tim whitfield replied on Permalink

Please, take responsibility for the NHS yourselves. It's probably not the easiest option for you, but you can set an example to others that the UK can manage these things.

Angela Walls replied on Permalink

Our NHS is precious. This white paper is opening the door to disaster for the British public. Please withdraw it.

bill plews replied on Permalink

Hands off OUR NHS.

jenni ford replied on Permalink

shame on this government to try and sneak this through when we are just beginning to relax a little and have hope for the future.

I was aware that they had been working towards this and it explains why they have resisted a pay rise for NHS workers who have served us so well through the pandemic-which may not yet have ended.The audacity of them is un believable.

THIS governments tactics are an absolute disgrace and beyond human. I have lived through several governments over my 74 years but this one is by far the worst! We must fight to the bone against this nonsense and hopefully unseat these greedy self serving people and their buddies for ever.

John Harrison replied on Permalink

More committees, more red tape, more bureaucracy, more expenses accounts for faceless mandarins, more money going out of the NHS budget instead of the monies being used by the UK Government to treat UK patients. This white paper is not in the interest of the NHS original protocol.

I say NO to this white paper.

Jayne Linney replied on Permalink

The #NHS is Exactly What is says National Health Service - FREE FOR ALL and MUST Stay So

Tom jestico replied on Permalink

The NHS has demonstrated that, free of privatisation and government interference, it is capable of the efficient use of resources - look at the vaccination roll out programme - but the biggest danger is the constant pressure to reorganise it. It’s certainly not perfect - too many administrators and needless bureaucracy - but the last thing it needs is privatisation.

Robert Reid replied on Permalink

Our NHS is something we should be proud of and not sold so that large companies can make profits out of sick people.

Peter DAVID Day replied on Permalink

All this white paper will do is to allow the privatization of ''OUR N H S '' and hand it all over the USA . The Tory's want this as they all have shares in the PRIVATE HOSPITALS AND MEDICAL INSURANCE companies. My excellent NHS surgeon wanted to operate on my back for the 5th time but said to me in the presents of my wife and 3 junior medical student QUOTE I WILL FRIST HAVE TO APPLY TO THOSE ''JOCKER IN NO 10'' FOR THE MONEY AND I EXPECT THEY WILL REFUSE TO GIVE IT TO ME. .Soon after that consultation he left the NHS CENTER OF EXCELLENCE AT RONH STANMORE HOSPITAL AFTER YEARS ON BEING ONE OF THE TOP NHS SURGEONS. IAM STILL WAITING FOR HELP AND MY BACK IS NOW GETTING WORES AFTER 4 YEARS OF HOPING THAT THEY WILL HELP ME .PETEE DAY

simon smith replied on Permalink

This white paper shows exactly why this goverment's priorities are completely wrong and all their promises false.

Alan AA Gasparutti replied on Permalink

The NHS belongs to the country. It is not for privatisation. Government actions have damaged society, made the poor poorer, who simply cannot afford private health care. Similarly, cuts to salaries results in fewer people prepared to pay towards private pensions.

Can you not see that your policies will destroy society and ultimately, the UK.

Pam Homer replied on Permalink

The National Health Service was set up for the good of the British people to ensure that we had free service when we needed it and NOT for profit of big business. DO NOT ALLOW IT TO BE SOLD OFF.

Michael Vyvyan replied on Permalink

The NHS needs to be funded and operated as a public entity without wasting money on PFIs, tendering processes and profit oriented businesses. It needs to incorporate social care so that it provides cradle to grave care. It also needs to own and operate more of its supply chain which could include manufacturing of PPE. Of course this would require improved and focussed management within the NHS and a body to provide independent scrutiny of its services, priorities, development and funding. Thought must be given to improving NHS IT systems and reducing the level of bureaucracy that hinders its efficient operation. As this white paper does not provide for these essential changes it should be rejected and the government forced to rethink its national care strategy.

Richard Haysom replied on Permalink

We must ensure that profits are NOT main consideration when dealing with NHS and selling and tendering parts off.

If wide open “Cherry picking” starts and the NHS is open to profit comes first not patients. Standards slip and overall we have a fragmented service.

Les Gearing replied on Permalink

The reason for the health services is the nations Health and that is all!

Privatization is firstly profit first , health very much second,

Recent moves in that direction proves it doesn't work.

keep it as it was created for.

Jenifer Trythall replied on Permalink

There should be no place for private profit in the NHS.

Alison Little replied on Permalink

Please keep our great NHS as it always has been, there to support all of us in the UK, and not private companies for their profit.

Patricia Charles replied on Permalink

This bill is far far too dangerous.

Halcyon Leonard replied on Permalink

Professor Levi,who is Dutch, and is just stepping down as chief exec. of UCLH is quoted in the Guardian (19th March 2021) as saying 'I'd never heard of PFI before I came here' Its a crazy system, a stupid system' and points to the gross waste of public money involved in repaying the loans required to build the main new part of University College hospital.

Kay Trotter replied on Permalink

The NHS is the backbone of our society providing free comprehensive medical support for everyone. Previous governments used to ensure that all its funding went on providing a first class service and decent wages for all employees. Now this government is putting profit over people selling off services to private contractors who hoard their profits, provide inadequate services for the majority of the population and do not provide employees with a decent income. We will soon be like the USA where millions suffer from poor medical provision .

Anonymous replied on Permalink

Definately stop this from happening we need our NHS .Stop this BILL !

ROB carruthers replied on Permalink

this must be stopped

Pages

Add new comment